The BEST Pizza Places in NYC You Must Try
The BEST Pizza Places in NYC You Must Try
New York City is synonymous with great pizza, and it’s no surprise the city boasts some of the best slices in the world. From classic thin crusts to creative gourmet pies, NYC has something to satisfy every pizza lover. Here’s a list of must-try pizza spots that define the city’s love affair with this cheesy delight.
1. Di Fara Pizza
📍 Location: 1424 Avenue J, Brooklyn
💰 Price: $$
What to Order: Classic Cheese Pizza, Square Slice
Di Fara is a NYC institution, with decades of history and a reputation for serving some of the best pizza in the world. Each pie is hand-crafted by Domenico DeMarco and family, ensuring a perfect balance of fresh mozzarella, basil, olive oil, and their secret tomato sauce.
Why Go: The authentic, old-school experience and unbeatable flavors make it worth the wait in line.
2. Joe’s Pizza
📍 Locations: Multiple (Greenwich Village, Times Square, etc.)
💰 Price: $
What to Order: Plain Cheese Slice
Joe’s Pizza is the quintessential NYC slice joint, beloved by locals and tourists alike. The thin crust and perfectly seasoned sauce create a classic New York slice you’ll dream about long after your visit.
Why Go: Quick, affordable, and delicious—perfect for on-the-go pizza cravings.
3. Lucali
📍 Location: 575 Henry St, Brooklyn
💰 Price: $$$
What to Order: Plain Pie with Extra Garlic
Lucali is famous for its romantic ambiance and wood-fired pies. Each pizza is crafted with fresh ingredients and topped with a blend of mozzarella and grana padano cheese. The BYOB policy adds to the charm, making it ideal for date nights.
Why Go: A bucket-list spot for foodies and pizza enthusiasts.
4. Prince Street Pizza
📍 Location: 27 Prince St, Manhattan
💰 Price: $$
What to Order: Spicy Pepperoni Square
Known for its thick, Sicilian-style crust, Prince Street Pizza’s Spicy Pepperoni Square is legendary. Each slice is loaded with crispy, cup-shaped pepperoni and a tangy, spicy sauce that packs a punch.
Why Go: A bold and flavorful twist on traditional pizza.
5. Patsy’s Pizzeria
📍 Location: 2287 1st Ave, Manhattan (Harlem)
💰 Price: $$
What to Order: Coal-Fired Margherita Pizza
Patsy’s has been serving authentic coal-fired pizza since 1933, and it remains a go-to spot for thin, crispy pies with classic toppings. Their Margherita pizza is a must-try for its simplicity and incredible taste.
Why Go: A slice of history with every bite.
6. Rubirosa Ristorante
📍 Location: 235 Mulberry St, Manhattan
💰 Price: $$$
What to Order: Vodka Sauce Pizza
Rubirosa elevates pizza to a gourmet level with their signature Vodka Sauce Pizza. The thin crust and rich, creamy vodka sauce are unlike anything else in the city.
Why Go: Perfect for a sit-down meal with creative and indulgent options.
7. John’s of Bleecker Street
📍 Location: 278 Bleecker St, Manhattan
💰 Price: $$
What to Order: White Pizza, Sausage Pie
John’s of Bleecker Street is a coal-fired pizza haven that’s been satisfying New Yorkers since 1929. Their white pizza, topped with garlic, ricotta, and mozzarella, is a fan favorite.
Why Go: Classic pizza served in a timeless NYC setting.
8. Scarr’s Pizza
📍 Location: 22 Orchard St, Manhattan
💰 Price: $–$$
What to Order: Plain Slice, Sicilian Slice
Scarr’s Pizza offers a retro vibe and pizzas made with freshly milled flour on-site. Their Sicilian slice is thick, airy, and bursting with flavor, while their plain slice is a love letter to classic NYC pizza.
Why Go: A trendy spot with a nostalgic twist.
9. Emily
📍 Locations: West Village, Brooklyn
💰 Price: $$$
What to Order: The Emmy Burger Pizza
Emily serves creative pies with bold toppings, but the standout is their Emmy Burger Pizza, inspired by their award-winning burger. The mix of mozzarella, caramelized onions, and burger sauce is a game-changer.
Why Go: For an innovative take on pizza with top-tier ingredients.
10. Lombardi’s Pizza
📍 Location: 32 Spring St, Manhattan
💰 Price: $$
What to Order: Classic Margherita
Lombardi’s holds the title of America’s first pizzeria, established in 1905. Their coal-fired pies are steeped in history and flavor, making it a must-visit for any pizza enthusiast.
Why Go: To experience the birthplace of American pizza.
Final Thoughts
New York City’s pizza scene is as diverse as the city itself, offering everything from traditional slices to gourmet creations. Whether you’re a die-hard pizza lover or just looking for a great meal, these spots are guaranteed to satisfy your cravings.
Which one will you try first? Let us know your favorite NYC pizza spots in the comments! 🍕